Research Motivation and Purpose
Recent literature has increasingly suggested that not all extracurricular activities contribute equally to students' academic achievement, and that the educational benefits of extracurricular participation may vary across activity types. Moreover, most previous studies have focused on the effects of participation in a particular category of extracurricular activity, rather than adopting a comprehensive perspective to compare academic outcomes across different forms of participation.
Drawing on a sample of 2,594 junior high school students, this study classified extracurricular involvement into seven categories: baseball school team, music and folklore club, sports school team, sports clubs, disciplinary and service clubs, other clubs, and non-participants. Given that participation in the baseball school team is particularly popular in Taitung and has been characterized by relatively low academic performance and substantial participation among Indigenous students, the baseball school team was designated as the reference group for comparison.
The study aimed to examine differences in basic test scores between members of the baseball school team and students in the other six groups, thereby testing whether participation in different types of extracurricular activities is associated with differential academic outcomes. In addition, the study incorporated three dimensions of family capital– cultural capital, financial capital, and social capital– to investigate the pathways through which these mediating factors influence students' basic test scores. Through this approach, the study sought to clarify both the direct and indirect relationships between extracurricular participation and academic achievement.
Literature Review
The classification of extracurricular activities in this study was informed by prior research indicating that academic outcomes may differ across the baseball school team, sports school team, and general sports clubs; therefore, these groups were examined separately. In addition, artistic activities are associated with the development of aesthetic appreciation and cognitive skills, while traditional folk-art activities contribute to the accumulation of cultural knowledge and competencies that may be converted into educational advantages. Accordingly, participation in bands, choirs, and folk-art activities was combined into a single category, the music and folklore club.
Regarding the mediating variables, the literature suggests that cultural capital plays an important role in educational attainment, although evidence in Taiwan remains limited. A small number of studies have reported that refined forms of cultural capital positively influence academic achievement, whereas disadvantaged hobby culture and disadvantaged leisure culture may be associated with lower academic performance. Research has also consistently shown that greater family financial resources, higher socioeconomic status, and richer educational resources increase students' learning opportunities and contribute to higher basic test scores. Furthermore, parental educational involvement and educational expectations constitute important forms of family social capital. Families with more abundant economic and social resources tend to provide stronger educational support and higher expectations, thereby enhancing students' social capital and promoting superior academic achievement.
Methods
This study utilized survey data on extracurricular activity participation collected from eighth-grade students in the Taitung Educational Longitudinal Database (TELD). Academic performance was measured using students' Basic Test Scores obtained from the Basic Competence Test administered during their transition from junior high school to senior high school. Multiple regression analyses were conducted to achieve several objectives. First, differences in Basic Test Scores across seven extracurricular activity groups were examined. Second, after controlling for demographic variables, the academic performance of students in the baseball school team was compared with that of students in the other six groups. Third, three dimensions of family capital were incorporated into the model to assess the mediating influence of family resources on the relationship between extracurricular participation and Basic Test Scores. Finally, the mediating pathways through which participation in the baseball school team and the music and folklore club affected Basic Test Scores were identified.
In addition, extracurricular participation was further dichotomized into two groups—baseball school team and non-baseball school team participants. Ethnic background and eighth-grade standardized test performance were controlled to clarify the factors underlying the comparatively lower Basic Test Scores observed among students in the baseball school team. Particular attention was given to the mediating roles of family resources, including cultural capital, in explaining variations in academic achievement.
Results
Regression analyses revealed that students in the baseball school team obtained the lowest basic test scores among the seven extracurricular activity groups, lending further support to the view that academic outcomes differ according to the type of extracurricular participation. The lower basic test scores of the baseball school team, relative to those of the sports school team, were largely attributable to ethnic background factors. The analyses further identified both direct and indirect pathways linking extracurricular participation to basic test scores, with family cultural capital, financial capital, and social capital serving as important mediating mechanisms. The comparatively lower basic test scores of students in the baseball school team were associated not only with their demographic and family-background characteristics– including a higher proportion of Indigenous students, an all-male composition, lower maternal educational attainment, and a greater prevalence of fathers engaged in manual labor occupations– but also with lower levels of refined cultural capital, lower levels of unfavorable hobby culture, and higher levels of parental computer guidance.
Moreover, the findings demonstrated that the lower basic test scores of the baseball school team could not be fully attributed either to Indigenous status or to lower academic performance in the eighth grade. Finally, students in the music and folklore club exhibited higher levels of refined cultural capital, which contributed to superior basic test scores, thereby providing additional support for the theoretical proposition that cultural capital enhances academic achievement.
Discussion and Recommendations
The findings indicate that academic achievement varied across different categories of extracurricular participation. The relatively lower basic test scores of students in the baseball school team could not be fully explained by Indigenous background or prior academic performance in eighth grade. Rather, these outcomes may reflect the combined influence of educational aspirations, rural backgrounds, sport-oriented career pathways, training demands, and institutional factors such as sports-specialized programs. Therefore, the findings should not be interpreted as evidence that participation in a baseball school team necessarily leads to lower academic achievement.
Several limitations warrant caution. The dataset did not include important psychological variables, such as learning motivation, self-efficacy, and resilience, preventing further control of their potential effects. In addition, the data were drawn from students in Taitung around 2006 and primarily reflect the educational and athletic context of that period. Given substantial changes in school sports over the past two decades– including the institutionalization of sports education, increased academic support, career development services, athlete welfare, and greater protection of students' learning rights– the findings may not be directly generalizable to contemporary student athletes. Future research should employ more recent data to examine whether the relationship between participation in a baseball school team and academic achievement has changed over time.