Research Background and Purposes
Global citizenship education is regarded as an important avenue for enhancing the global mobility of younger generations and equipping them to assume global citizenship responsibilities. However, in the context of the “decolonial turn” in academia, there has been persistent critique of its underlying Western-centrism (or Eurocentrism). Taking Taiwan as an example, the purpose of its international education is to enhance students' global citizenship. However, its policy discourse is more or less imbued with Western-centric (or Eurocentric) ideologies. Without challenging Western-centric (or Eurocentric) assumptions, global citizenship education may reinforce the existing Western-centric (or Eurocentric) hegemonic hierarchies of knowledge and thoughts, thereby perpetuating neocolonialism and neoimperialism, and reproducing existing global epistemic injustice. Based on the above research background, the purposes of this paper are as follows:
- To analyze the origin and the structural factors underlying operation of Eurocentrism as revealed by Mignolo’s decolonial perspectives.
- To summarize the possible approaches to transcending Eurocentrism as indicated by Mignolo’s decolonial viewpoints.
- To explore the implications of Mignolo’s decolonial perspectives for constructing critical global citizenship education/global education/international education (critical GCE/GE/IE).
- To analyze the inherent limitations of Mignolo’s decolonial perspectives.
Methodology
The method of educational hermeneutics was adopted to achieve the above research purposes, including vorbereitende interpretation, textimmanente interpretation, and koordinierende interpretation. Vorbereitende interpretation involved analyzing and understanding Taiwan’s context and policy discourse surrounding international education, as well as Mignolo’s biography and academic background, which serve as the foundation for interpretation. Textimmanente interpretation consisted of a close reading of Mignolo’s works and categorizing the concepts and arguments contained within the texts. Koordinierende interpretation involved the researcher’s continuous connection of specific works by Mignolo with his other books, journal articles, or interviews, as well as referencing the relevant discussions by other scholars. Simultaneously, Taiwan’s current educational phenomena are incorporated to contextualize the interpretation within the local setting.
Mignolo’s Decolonial Viewpoints
The analysis results in this paper indicate that Eurocentrism originated from the operation of the colonial matrix of power within the modern/colonial world system. Its structural mechanisms consist of two levels: the enunciated and the apparatus of enunciation. The former includes four domains– knowledge/understanding, governance, economy, and classification– while the latter comprises three elements– institutions, actors, and languages.
In order to break free from Eurocentrism, Mignolo proposed “decolonial thinking” or “decolonizing knowledge” as a solution, which is composed of several strategies, including delinking, epistemic disobedience, and border thinking (specifically manifested in pluritopic hermeneutics).
Implications of Mignolo’s Decolonial Viewpoints for Critical GCE/GE/IE
- Educational scholars and practitioners can utilize the concept of colonial matrix of power to analyze the geopolitics of knowledge within GCE/GE/IE.
- Educational scholars and practitioners should reflect upon and deconstruct the Eurocentric presuppositions embedded in the terminology and mindsets of GCE/GE/IE.
- Teachers can employ pluritopic hermeneutics to broaden students’ pluriversal horizons of international affairs and global issues.
- Educational academics across different locales can utilize the strategies of border thinking to indigenize the epistemologies of GCE/GE/IE.
Limitations of Mignolo’s Viewpoints and Recommendations for Future Research
- Being rooted in one’s own cultural tradition is emphasized by Mignolo as an important decolonial strategy. However, as traditional culture faces near-extinction, how can we construct localized theoretical perspectives and epistemologies ex nihilo? Taiwan serves as a case in point: due to foreign colonization severing traditional cultural ties, Taiwan has long exhibited a strong tendency to eagerly embrace and swiftly assimilate foreign cultures. The “self-emptying” orientation presumes that Taiwan’s cultures are inadequate and crude, thus compelled to seek from outside. In the context of severe scarcity of indigenous cultural traditions and academic resources, the pursuit of these assets to construct GCE/GE/IE theoretical viewpoints and epistemology with local characteristics will be an extremely arduous task.
- Mignolo attempts to idealize and romanticize non-Western perspectives and “indigenous episteme” in search of an antidote to coloniality. However, this episteme is often depicted in a static, essentialist, and ahistorical way, which risks reinforcing an essentialist view of the Global South or indigenous knowledge. This could easily lead to the narrowing of one’s own vision through binary logic of “West/non-West”, “Global North/Global South”, and “domination/subordination”, which aligns with the frameworks of ethnonationalism or localism.
- In the pursuit of a pluriversal horizon that incorporates diverse epistemic traditions, value systems, and worldviews from around the world, a prominent practical challenge is the issue of language. Epistemological discourses and cultural traditions from the Global South are often conveyed through local languages (rather than global lingua franca), which presents a significant linguistic barrier for educators engaged in GCE/GE/IE teaching or scholars conducting related research.
- Mignolo’s decolonial viewpoints are overly focused on the epistemological dimension, neglecting the significance of political power, economic structures, and social practices in the struggle against oppression and the achievement of emancipation goals.
- Based on the aforementioned implications and limitations, it is suggested that future research conduct a genealogical analysis of past local (e.g., Taiwanese) scholarly works on GCE/GE/IE. This analysis should examine the ideologies embedded in Western GCE/GE/IE theoretical perspectives and the impacts they have engendered, and identify traditional resources that can be applied to the formulation of indigenized GCE/GE/IE theoretical perspectives and epistemologies. Furthermore, in order to decolonize GCE/GE/IE thoughts and practice, it is essential to first understand how teachers envision GCE/GE/IE and its knowledge and learning that transcend Eurocentric paradigms. This understanding can serve as a foundational basis for the development of decolonial-oriented GCE/GE/IE curricula in teacher training and professional development. Additionally, future research could also explore the theoretical perspectives of other decolonial thinkers, such as N. Maldonado-Torres, B. de Souza Santos, L. T. Smith, and R. Grosfoguel, in greater depth.
Conclusion
At the end of the paper, the researcher proposed an approach of “decolonial-oriented critical GCE towards a pluriversal horizon.” In this approach, scholars in the field of education, when analyzing Western theories, ideologies, conceptual frameworks, educational policies or programs, and assessment schemes related to GCE/GE/IE, can adopt a perspective informed by the geopolitics of knowledge. They can utilize the concept of colonial matrix of power to examine the potential causes, structural factors, and consequences of epistemic colonization, and employ the strategies of border thinking to break free from Eurocentrism. On the other hand, teachers, in the process of planning and designing curricula and instructional activities for GCE/GE/IE, can apply the concept of colonial matrix of power to analyze the Eurocentrist underpinnings inherent in Western digital and physical teaching materials and resources. In the classroom, educators can guide students to critically reflect on the asymmetrical power dynamics embedded within the process of knowledge production, its international dissemination, and the reception (consumption) of such knowledge, and the resulting consequences of global epistemic injustice.