Enhancing students’ ability to resolve complex socioscientific issues (SSIs) has been one of the focuses of science education in recent years. SSIs are viewed as multifaceted, debatable problems with various perspectives, resulting in conflicts and dilemmas for which clear solutions are difficult to achieve. Students often experience inner conflict or frustration when facing such complex issues and being aware of various perspectives that differ from their own. In the current study, a three-phase decision-making framework was adopted to formulate a web-based SSI module (with six periods of class time spanning 2 weeks), and it was implemented in four classes of 11th grade in a senior high school. After recognizing and evaluating the different perspectives of stakeholders in the issue of a gas transportation station in a coastal area, students were randomly assigned to study and enact roleplay or role reversal as one of the stakeholders. Ninety-eight senior high school students’ comments and reflections on their final position on the SSI and their perceptions of social emotion were examined to explore the differences between the effects of roleplay and role reversal on students’ SSI decision-making with perspective-taking (DM-PT). The results indicated that after the implementation, some of the students were willing to consider incorporating opposite perspectives and to seek compensation plans as remedies for a win-win solution. Moreover, role reversal was found to be more effective than roleplay in terms of fostering the students’ perspective-taking during their SSI decision-making and resulting in the change of their final position, regardless of whether they agreed or disagreed with the construction of a gas transportation station. However, additional explicit scaffolding is required for those students who do not demonstrate DM-PT reflection, particularly those who practice role reversal and have less-positive social emotions regarding social awareness, relationship skills, and responsible decision-making. The implications of these findings for SSI instruction are discussed.