This study aims to analyze the learning portfolios of technical high school students and propose strategic responses for policy adjustments as well as solutions to the challenges faced in school curricula and instruction. Based on the triadic reciprocal causation among personal attributions, environmental influences, and intentional behaviors as elucidated in Social Cognitive Theory (SCT), a theoretical model was constructed to empirically validate the critical factors influencing the development of learning portfolios. Specifically, this study establishes a Serial Mediation Model to examine the relationships, designating learning reflection as the initial variable, academic advancement tool cognition and interdisciplinary learning participation as the mediating factors, and learning self-efficacy as the outcome variable. A questionnaire survey method was adopted, targeting first-year undergraduate students enrolled in the electrical and mechanical engineering departments across five technological universities, including two in northern, one in central, and one in southern Taiwan, yielding a total sample size of 326 students. Utilizing Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) for analysis, this study investigates the effectiveness of students’ learning portfolios, with a particular focus on different family and school supervision environments. Ultimately, the empirical results indicate significant direct and indirect relationships among students’ learning reflection, academic advancement tool cognition (intentions), interdisciplinary learning participation, and learning self-efficacy. More precisely, the learning reflection of technical high school students exerts a full mediation effect on their learning self-efficacy through the sequential mediating roles of academic advancement tool cognition and interdisciplinary learning participation. In other words, guiding students to establish a proper cognition of the portfolio as an advancement tool and substantially increasing their participation in interdisciplinary learning are the keys to enhancing students’ learning self-efficacy.