Many brands nowadays are developing towards omni-channel retailing. With logistics as the last mile in the retailing channel, the literature has mostly focused on forward logistics, but few studies have explored the return experience in reverse logistics. Based on the expectation-confirmation theory, this research thus explores the impact of perceived return policy, the quality of return service on return service satisfaction, and customer loyalty in omni-channel retailing. The results herein show that perceived rational return policy positively affects the satisfaction with return service, but there is no such relationship with expectation confirmation. The quality of return service positively shapes the confirmation of expectations and satisfaction with return services, and the confirmation of expectations even improves satisfaction with return services. The loyalty of customers is also influenced by the satisfaction with return services. Finally, the coefficients of behavioral path are different under diversity return channels. From the findings, this study proposes management implications for practitioners.