A 61-year-old female restaurant caterer had received regular annual health examinations. In 2015, hepatitis A virus immunoglobulin M antibody (anti-HAV IgM) was detected, though she showed no symptom or sign of HAV infection. She was then transferred to the gastroenterology (GI) outpatient clinic where she underwent further laboratory tests that revealed no specific findings. Medical certificates were therefore issued and regular follow-ups arranged. However, reactive anti-HAV IgM persisted with reactive result of anti-HAV IgG in 2016, and laboratory tests again showed negative findings. She was accordingly admitted for liver biopsy. Nevertheless, the pathology report also revealed no sign or symptom of infection, and she did not report any symptoms of HAV infection. As a result, she was discharged for annual monitoring. During the period from 2017 to 2020, she had visited our family medicine outpatient clinic for regular follow-ups; anti-HAV IgM and anti-HAV IgG were followed and revealed reactive findings. Persistent anti-HAV IgM is rare in the literature, and concurrent persistent anti-HAV IgG is even more unusual. In this article, we present a rare case of the above condition while the literature of persistent anti-HAV IgM is also reviewed.