This article re-examines Arthur Wing Pinero’s The Second Mrs. Tanqueray through the lens of Erving Goffman’s sociological framework, specifically placing his dramaturgical analysis of impression management into dialogue with his theory of stigma. While traditional readings of the play often focus on Paula Tanqueray’s psychological instability or the tragic inevitability of her past, this paper argues that her suicide is the terminal consequence of a failed performative system. By analyzing the domestic sphere as a stage where the "backstage" has been repurposed into a site of surveillance, I demonstrate how Paula’s efforts to "cover" her stigmatized identity are rendered futile by the very individuals mandated to support her performance. Ultimately, this article maintains that Pinero’s drama functions as an indictment of a normative system that demands the labor of the stigmatized to maintain a respectable facade, only to dismantle that same labor when it no longer suffices to conceal the perceived taint. Through this Goffmanian approach, I illustrate that the play’s catastrophe is not merely a personal tragedy but a structural collapse necessitated by the inherent impossibility of performing "normalcy" under the gaze of judges disguised as partners.