一位國小校長在學校與社區互動的意義建構

A Study on an Elementary School Principal’s Sensemaking in the Interactions Between School and Community

研究目的

學校坐落於社區中，與社區關係密切，校長身為學校領導者，承載著帶領學校與外部環境互動之重責大任，校長所做的各項決定，往往建基於其對學校內、外部情境的理解與意義建構，並會對學校產生重要影響。然而，先前有關學校與社區關係的文獻，探討校長衡酌學校內、外部社區環境以領導學校的意義建構之研究，尚不多見，因此，本研究的目的主要在探討一位國小校長所解讀的與社區互動的關鍵事件、其意義建構的思考行動特徵，以及可能影響因素。

主要理論或概念架構

學校與社區關係之相關研究大多從互動類型、學校行銷、學校與社區夥伴關係、學校實施特色課程或校長角色等角度進行分析，從意義建構（sensemaking）觀點探討校長如何篩選環境中的重要訊息或線索，並對其進行理解和詮釋，據此採取適當行動以因應不斷變化教育現場的相關研究尚不多見。由於探究校長意義建構有助於瞭解學校領導者思考及學習歷程的經驗與特性，因此，本研究採用意義建構觀點分析國民小學校長領導學校與社區互動之意義建構，盼能彌補現有文獻之不足，同時提供實務參考建議。

研究設計／方法／對象

本研究運用質性研究取向的個案研究法，探討一位國小校長與社區互動的意義建構特性。透過立意取樣中的效標抽樣（criterion sampling），選定一所國小及其所在的社區作為研究場域，於2023年8月初至11月中旬，以半結構式訪談瞭解個案學校與社區互動的實際情形，研究參與者共計五位，包含個案校長，以及與社區互動關鍵事件有關之校內外成員。研究者首先和校長討論其所認定個案學校與社區互動的關鍵事件，並從中瞭解校長對事件的解讀及行動，接續由校長所提及之事件找尋相關人士進行訪談，據此瞭解不同觀點，以及達到交互檢證之效。

研究發現或結論

根據研究目的，本研究獲得之結論如下：

一、個案校長所解讀與社區互動的關鍵事件包括家長會角色、學校特色課程、衝突化解、學區外學生增長，以及家校合作。

二、個案校長意義建構之思考行動特徵為優先提升學校品質，獲取社區認肯、提供討論及交流機會，以及給予成員支持。

三、個案校長在關鍵事件中的意義建構受到少子女化趨勢、角色身分、職涯經驗與成長歷程影響。

理論或實務創見／貢獻／建議

根據研究結論，本研究對個案學校校長及未來研究的建議如下：

一、擴展入學面試至學區內的學生與家長，溝通理念，提升其對學校理念及特色課程的理解及認識。

二、建立較為全面分析與回饋機制，以促進學校發展；

三、進行更多以意義建構觀點分析學校校長領導的學習經驗研究。

Purpose

Schools are located within their communities and maintain close interactions with them. As school leaders, principals bear the responsibility of interacting with their surrounding environments. The decisions they make are often based on their understanding and sensemaking of the internal and external contexts of the school and have a significant impact on the school. However, previous literature on schoolcommunity relations has offered limited examination of how principals incorporate internal and external community contexts into their sensemaking processes. The study explores the key events of interaction with the community as interpreted by an elementary school principal, the thinking and action characteristics of his sensemaking, and possible influencing factors.

Main Theories or Conceptual Frameworks

Previous studies have predominantly analyzed the types of interaction, school marketing, school-community partnerships, school implementation of featured curricula, or roles of the principals. They are, however, limited to how school leaders filter important information or cues from the environment, interpret them, and take appropriate actions in response to the constantly changing educational sites through the perspective of sensemaking. Therefore, this study adopts sensemaking to analyze the interactions between a principal and the surrounding community, which not only enriches existing research but also provides suggestions for the implementation in practice.

Research Design/Methods/Participants

This study utilizes a qualitative case study method to explore the sensemaking characteristics of an elementary school principal’s interactions with the community. Through criterion-based purposive sampling, one elementary school and its surrounding community were selected as the research site. Between early August and mid-November 2023, semi-structured interviews were conducted to understand the actual interactions between the case school and the community. A total of five participants were involved in the study, including the principal, and key stakeholders within and outside the school who were related to key events in community interactions. The researchers first discuss with the principal who identified five primary critical events related to school and community interactions. With the aim to understand the principal’s interpretations and actions on those events, the researchers conduct interviews with the stakeholders to capture multiple perspectives, and to achieve cross-validation.

Research Findings or Conclusions

Based on the research purposes, the conclusions of this study are as follows:

1. The critical events interpreted by the principal regarding the interactions between the school and the community include the role of parent-teacher associations, the school’s featured curriculum, addressing conflict, the increasing enrollment of students from outside the school district, and collaboration between families and the school.

2. Prioritizing efforts to improve school quality and to gain community recognition, providing opportunities to discuss and exchange opinions, and offering supports to all the parties are the sensemaking characteristics that appear repeatedly in critical events of the principal.

3. The principal’s sensemaking in critical events was influenced by factors such as declining birthrate trends, role identity, career experiences, and the principal’s professional development trajectory.

Theoretical or Practical Insights/Contributions/Recommendations

Based on the aforementioned conclusions, this study presents suggestions for the principal of the case study school and future research as followed.

1. Implement the admission interview for students and parents within the school district to strengthen communications in order to enhance their comprehension of the school’s ideology and featured curriculum.

2. Develop comprehensive analysis and feedback mechanisms to promote school development.

3. Conduct studies on the learning experience of school principal leadership from a sensemaking perspective.