月旦知識庫
月旦知識庫 會員登入|元照網路書店|月旦品評家
 
 
  1. 熱門:
首頁 臺灣期刊   法律   公行政治   醫事相關   財經   社會學   教育   其他 大陸期刊   核心   重要期刊 DOI文章
運動文化研究 本站僅提供期刊文獻檢索。
  【月旦知識庫】是否收錄該篇全文,敬請【登入】查詢為準。
最新【購點活動】


篇名
教學與性騷擾之界線──從比例原則之實質審查檢視中學體育科不適任教師之懲處
並列篇名
Teaching vs. Sexual Harassment: A Substantive Review of Disciplining Unfit High School P.E. Teachers Under the Principle of Proportionality
中文摘要
近年來校園性別平等意識持續深化,體育教學現場的師生身體界線問題已成為教育行政法學的重要議題。體育學科因涉及動作示範、技能引導與安全防護,無可避免的包含師生間之肢體接觸;當此類具備教學目的之指導被指控為性騷擾時,行政機關與法院往往面臨「教學必要性」與「身體自主權」之界線衝突。本文以臺北高等行政法院111年度訴字第1454號判決為核心案例,輔以臺中高等行政法院113年度簡字第24號判決作為比較觀察,檢視行政機關、學校教師評審委員會與行政法院在處理體育教師性騷擾懲處案件時,是否對比例原則進行實質審查。結果認為現行實務存在三項系統性缺失:其一,混淆性別平等教育委員會之「判斷餘地」與教評會之「行政裁量」兩個性質截然不同之行政法概念,導致比例原則在懲處裁量階段形同虛設;其二,事實認定階段未能引入「合理被害人」客觀化標準,任由被害人主觀感受取代客觀情境之審查,此一瑕疵向下延伸至懲處裁量層次,形成兩個層次審查缺失相互疊加之制度性根源;其三,比例原則之審查流於定型化文字,呈現不論情節輕重一律解聘之齊頭式重刑化傾向,嚴重侵害教師受憲法第15條保障之工作權,並引發體育教學現場之防禦性教學效應。針對上述困境,建議主張國家在行使懲戒權剝奪教師工作權時,必須建立具體化之「實質比例原則三階層審查基準」,涵蓋適當性、必要性與衡平性,並輔以「合理被害人」客觀化標準。為此,本文提出「主客觀審酌矩陣」作為操作工具,以主觀意圖、客觀情境與侵害程度三個維度之交叉評估,將教育部112年9月26日函示所揭示之審酌因素轉化為可操作之階層化裁量框架,精準區分教學溝通瑕疵、過度接觸與蓄意侵犯三個違規層次,期能在保護學生免受性別暴力與保障體育教師合法工作權之間,實現符合法治國原則之衡平正義。
英文摘要
As gender equity awareness deepens in educational institutions, physical boundaries between teachers and students in physical education (PE) have become a significant issue in educational administrative law. Because PE instruction inherently requires physical contact for movement demonstration, skill facilitation, and safety spotting, conflicts between pedagogical necessity and bodily autonomy frequently arise when such contact is alleged to constitute sexual harassment. This paper takes Taipei High Administrative Court Judgment 111-Su-1454 as its core case, supplemented by Taichung High Administrative Court Judgment 113-Jian-24 as a comparative reference, to examine whether administrative agencies, school teacher evaluation committees (TECs), and administrative courts conduct substantive proportionality review in disciplinary proceedings against PE teachers accused of sexual harassment. Three systemic deficiencies are identified. First, current practice conflates the ''margin of appreciation'' accorded to Gender Equity Education Committees (GEECs) at the fact-finding stage with the ''administrative discretion'' exercised by TECs at the sanctioning stage, causing courts to abdicate substantive proportionality review under the guise of deference to professional expertise. Second, the absence of a ''reasonable victim'' standard at the fact-finding stage allows subjective victim perception to displace objective contextual scrutiny, a deficiency that cascades into the sanctioning stage and compounds into a systemic cause of disproportionate punishment. Third, proportionality review has been reduced to formulaic boilerplate, producing a one-size-fits-all dismissal tendency that infringes upon teachers' constitutionally protected right to work under Article 15 and generates a chilling defensive teaching effect in PE classrooms. In response, this paper argues that the state must establish substantive three-tier proportionality review criteria—encompassing suitability, necessity, and proportionality stricto sensu—supplemented by a reasonable victim standard. The paper further proposes a Subjective-Objective Review Matrix that assesses subjective intent, objective context, and degree of harm, translating the Ministry of Education's Directive of September 26, 2023 into a tiered framework distinguishing among communicative teaching deficiency, excessive physical contact, and deliberate assault, with differentiated disciplinary recommendations for each tier. The ultimate aim is to strike a principled balance between protecting students from gender-based violence and safeguarding PE teachers' lawful right to work.
起訖頁 101-141
關鍵詞 合理被害人、性別平等教育法、標準判斷餘地、體育教學、administrative discretion、Gender Equity Education Act、margin of appreciation、physical education、reasonable victim standard
刊名 運動文化研究  
期數 202603 (48期)
出版單位 國立清華大學當代中國研究中心
該期刊-上一篇 專注的藝術──壘球心流生成的自我敘說與詮釋
 

新書閱讀



最新影音


優惠活動




讀者服務專線:+886-2-23756688 傳真:+886-2-23318496
地址:臺北市館前路28 號 7 樓 客服信箱
Copyright © 元照出版 All rights reserved. 版權所有,禁止轉貼節錄