辨析《臺灣歷史辭典》〈南拜山〉真正應該註明的參考書目

Discrimination and Analysis of the Bibliography That Should Be Indicated in ''Minami Haizan'' of Dictionary of Taiwan History

南拜山爲日本九州福岡士族，修習漢醫；曾於一九三○年來臺，爲支援「臺灣皇漢醫道復活運動」，進行巡迴演講。《臺灣歷史辭典》收錄有〈南拜山〉詞目，撰稿者爲許雪姬。然而，許雪姬在該詞目正文之後所附的參考書目，註明爲〈南拜山翁略歷〉，顯有不當。本論文從相關領域的學術研究發展史，釐清該主題的學術貢獻誰屬；復透過文本比對，發現在該詞目總字數259字當中，文字敘述出自〈南拜山翁略歷〉者，共37字，僅佔總字數的14.29%；而與陳君愷《日治時期臺灣醫生社會地位之研究》該書內容文字敘述完全一致者，竟多達144字，佔總字數的55.60%。可知該詞目所附的參考書目，應該爲《日治時期臺灣醫生社會地位之研究》，並確認許雪姬抄襲與剽竊無疑。

Minami Haizanwas a shizoku from Fukuoka, Kyushu in Japan, who studied Kampōmedicine. He came to Taiwan in 1930 and gave lectures in support of the ''Taiwan Imperial KampōMedicine Revival Movement.'' The Dictionary of Taiwan History contains the entry ''Minami Haizan,'' written by Hsu Hsueh-Chi. However, the bibliography attached by Hsu Hsueh-Chi after the main text of the entry is marked as ''The Curriculum Vitae of the Elderly Man Minami Haizan,'' which is obviously inappropriate. Based on the development history of academic research in related fields, this thesis clarifies the academic contribution of this topic. Through text comparison, it is found that among the total 259 characters of this entry, the text description comes from ''The Curriculum Vitae of the Elderly Man Minami Haizan,'' a total of 37 characters, accounting for only 14.29% of the total number of words; and those that are completely consistent with the content of Chen Chun-Kai's A Study of Social Status of Taiwanese Doctors under Japanese Rules have as many as 144 characters, accounting for 55.60% of the total number of words. It can be seen that the bibliography attached to this entry should be A Study of Social Status of Taiwanese Doctors under Japanese Rules, and it is confirmed that Hsu Hsueh-Chi plagiarized and plagiarized.