月旦知識庫
 
  1. 熱門:
 
首頁 臺灣期刊   法律   公行政治   醫事相關   財經   社會學   教育   其他 大陸期刊   核心   重要期刊 DOI文章
早期中國史研究 本站僅提供期刊文獻檢索。
  【月旦知識庫】是否收錄該篇全文,敬請【登入】查詢為準。
最新【購點活動】


篇名
時代的異音:劉知幾及其友朋的學思特色探析
並列篇名
An Analysis of the Scholarly Thought of Liu Zhiji and His Close Friends
作者 黃庭碩 (Ting-shou Huang)
中文摘要

本文針對劉知幾(661-721)以及與他「道術相知」的幾位友朋── 徐堅(660-729)、朱敬則(635-709)、薛謙光(647-719)、劉允濟(生卒不詳)、元行沖(653-729)、吳兢(670-749)──進行學思上的分析,並主張他們共享著近似特色。首先,史學是貫串其學術特色的核心。在理念上,他們皆堅持秉筆直書的實錄理想;在實踐上,他們特重編年體史書的褒貶筆法,以及譜學整頓人倫的功能。基於史學撰作立場,他們對傳統章句之學,乃至經典本身發出不少質疑與批判,嘗試指出其中的非歷史、反實錄成分;其次,受到唐初史學日重人事的發展影響,他們一反當時流行的天人交感說,傾向將二者關係拉遠,並著眼人事本身;最後,他們強調史學寫作應以「徵實」為原則,多對魏晉以降漸次壯大的美文傳統感到不滿,不大願意肯定文學的獨立價值,反倒著重其政教功能,力主王教與道德乃文章之本。這些觀點在七、八世紀之交的知識界並非主流,可謂「時代的異音」,但他們的學思特色沒有及身而止,反倒在劉知幾諸子及元行沖外甥韋述(?-757)手上得到承傳,進而對蕭穎士(717-760)、李華(715?-774?)等文章中興領袖產生啟發。

 

英文摘要

This article analyzes the viewpoints of Liu Zhiji (661-721), the celebrated historian of the early Tang dynasty, and his close friends Xu Jian (660-729), Zhu Jingze (635-709), Xue Qianguang (647-719), Liu Yunji (ca. 650-710), Yuan Xingchong (653-729), and Wu Jing (670-749), on several scholarly issues, arguing that they had ideas in common that differed from the mainstream of their time. Like Liu Zhiji, most of his close friends had a keen interest in historiography and believed that ideal historical works, recording the truth faithfully without any distortions, could enhance the moral system and rebuild the social order. At the same time, they also tried to apply their experience of and criteria for historical writing to evaluate other scholarly issues. They criticized many distortions and fictions they found in commentaries on the classics, and even in the classics themselves. They doubted or rejected the popular correlative cosmology which linked the actions of heaven and man, observing that it was man rather than heaven that should take responsibility for successes or failures. Finally, they were dissatisfied with the ornate style that had dominated literary writing in past centuries; reluctant to confirm the independent value of literature, they held that literature should serve politics and be rooted in morality. Their opinions did not gain much interest while they were alive, but their voices did not disappear after they died. Inherited by Liu Zhiji’s sons and Yuan Xingchong’s nephew Wei Shu (d. 757), their intellectual heritage was not only promoted in the next generation, but also spread out from their small circle to inspire literati like Xiao Yingshi (717-760) and Li Hua (715?-774?), who would lead a major literary revival in the mid-eighth century.

 

起訖頁 171-248
關鍵詞 劉知幾史學書寫文學主張經傳批判天人思想文章中興Liu Zhijihistoriographyliterary perspectivecriticism on classical scholarshipthe relationship between heaven and manliterary revival
刊名 早期中國史研究  
期數 201912 (11期)
該期刊-上一篇 南朝的左郡左縣
該期刊-下一篇 秦法與秦國父系家庭的形成
 

新書閱讀



最新影音


優惠活動




讀者服務專線:+886-2-23756688 傳真:+886-2-23318496
地址:臺北市館前路28 號 7 樓 客服信箱
Copyright © 元照出版 All rights reserved. 版權所有,禁止轉貼節錄