Kaohsiung City is a modernized metropolitan inhabited mainly by Min Nan ethnic people. It is not one of the so-called “Major Developing Area of Hakka Culture,” but a city where Hakkanese is being minorized and invisualized along the course of history. However, the Hakka Language School Policy (HLSP) in Kaohsiung City has been implemented surprisingly well and come out with unanticipated policy outcomes: the participation percentage of non-Hakka schoolchildren exceeds that of Hakka schoolchildren in particular; the increasingly acceptance of multiculturalism among elementary school schoolchildren in general. How we explain this unexpected outcome of HLSP in Kaohsiung City, an urban area where Hakkanese social power is considered weak. More importantly, what were the motives of those participating schoolchildren? What were the substantial effects of HLSP on the Hakka and non-Hakka schoolchildren?
This empirical study examines policy effects of HLSP in Kaohsiung City implemented from 2003 to 2010. By using questionnaire and statistical analysis, our preliminary findings are: firstly, the major learning motives of schoolchildren participating HLSP are “wanting to know other ethnic cultures” and “Hakka language school is interesting.” Secondly, the HLSP has strengthened Hakka schoolchildren’s Hakka identity and the interest to learn more about Hakka culture and language among non-Hakka schoolchildren. As for the hypothesis testing of “ethnic identity,” “learning motive,” and “multiculturalism conception,” we find that the difference is significant in pairing comparison, but after post hoc comparisons the difference does not reach significant level. In other words, the learning motives and conception of multiculturalism of Hakka and non-Hakka schoolchildren are not much different; and thus, there is no proof of influence of schoolchildren’s ethnic background. Furthermore, the correlation analysis shows a significant positive correlation of “learning motives” and “multicultural conception”; namely, the motives to learn Hakkanese contributes significantly to the conceptualization of multiculturalism, and vice versa.