章太炎早年的「春秋左傳」學與清代「公羊」學的關係－－以「春秋左傳讀」為討論中心

The Relationship between Zhang Taiyan's Study on Chunqiu Zuozhuan in His Early Periods and the New Text School in the Qing Dynasty: Focusing on Chunqiu Zuozhuan du

近年學界對於章太炎早年的《春秋左傳》學與今文經學（《公羊》學）的關係，已有所揭示，唯各家之分析一般忽略了代表章氏早年《春秋左傳》學成果的《春秋左傳讀》。本文以《春秋左傳讀》為中心，分析章氏早年《左傳》學與今文經說（《公羊》學經說）的關係，尤其集中討論《春秋左傳讀》中，章氏在面對漢學求是與經世致用的經學目標之間，所呈現出來的矛盾態度，與其後來《左傳》學轉變的關係。Recently scholars have revealed the relationship between Zhang Taiyan's study of Chunqiu Zuozhuan in his early period and the theory of the New Text School (Gongyang xue). However, the related analyses have more often than not overlooked the contents of Chunqiu Zuozhuan du, which represents the achievement of Zhang's study of Chunqiu Zuozhuan in his early period. Therefore, this article focuses on Chunqiu Zuozhuan du, discussing the relationship between Zhang's study of Chunqiu Zuozhuan and the theory of the New Text School, so as to reveal the contradiction between qiushi 'pursuing truth' and zhiyong 'practical applicability' in Chunqiu Zuozhuan du, and how it inspired Zhang's change of view towards his study of Zuozhuan.