兩宋「論詞詩」及「論詞長短句」之價值

On the Values of “Ci Commentary in Shi (Ancient Verse)” and “Ci Commentary in Ci (Lyrical Form)” During the Song Dynasty

本論文係以兩宋文人所作之詩、詞中，涉及論詞之文字，予以彙錄整理。並歸納為三方面，舉蔡襄、周紫芝、范成大、劉克莊、毛珝、程正同、黃昇、王沂孫、張炎等人所作之詩、詞，論述其價值如次：一、擴大詞學批評之視野；二、提供輯佚考辨之線索；三、輔助建構論詞之觀點。由於此資料目前尚未有學者整理問世，故能藉以運用研究者，為數仍少；而此亦筆者出版《清代論詞絕句初編》後，持續上溯之系列蒐輯及研究，誠信對詞學研究有莫大裨益。

This essay aims to arrange and systematize Ci commentary in shi (ancient) verse and changduanju (Ci poetry) of the Song Dynasty. It will review and explore the literature of Song poets such as Tsai Xiang, Zhou Zizhi, Fan Chengda, Liu Kezhuang, Mao Xu, Cheng Zhengtong, Huang Sheng, Wang Yisun and Zhan Yan, literary figures that all made three major contributions in the art of Ci poetry: 1. To broaden the scope and range of Ci poetry criticism. 2. To provide clues in collecting and identifying anonymous materials. 3. To help develop perspectives of Ci poetry criticism. Research based on the collective study of Ci commentary is rare since these materials have yet to be systematically organized and arranged. This research is a continuation of my book, Qingdai Lunci Jueju chubian (Verses of Lyrical Commentary in the Qing Dynasty, First Volume.) In continuing this collection of materials and research, the author believes this essay will make a significant contribution to the study of Ci poetry.