篇名 | 二元民主論視域下“良性違憲”困境消解新路徑 |
---|---|
並列篇名 | A New Way to Resolve the Dilemma of "Benign Unconstitutional" from the Perspective of Dualist Democracy Theory |
作者 | 葉松奇 |
中文摘要 | 我國改革開放過程中存在的一些在當時看來屬於“違憲”的改革措施,被學界稱作“良性違憲”。多年來學界不斷提出不同觀點來解釋此現象,以爲改革正名,然迄今這一謎題仍未消解。美國憲法學者布魯斯·阿克曼提出的二元民主理論可爲“良性違憲”困境的消解提供新的理論資源。在日常政治和憲法時刻二元化語境中,憲法時刻表徵國家處在需要重大轉型的立憲時刻,“違憲”的非常規舉動往往是實現社會變革的必要條件。而此階段中人民出場與政治家進行深層互動並最終批准了整場變革,人民的意志消解了非常規轉型的合法性困題。我國“八二憲法”生成過程以及自20世紀70年代末至21世紀初的經濟體制改革可被視作我國憲法史上的兩次憲法時刻,那些“違憲”的非常規措施應放在這一情境中加以理解。非常規性是重大憲制轉型的必然邏輯,而這期間的人民動員則賦予了非常規改革舉措以正當性。 |
英文摘要 | In the process of reform and opening up, some reform measures existed at that time belong to the "unconstitutional", which was called "benign unconstitutional" by the academic circle. Over the years, different viewpoints have been put forward to explain this phenomenon in order to justify the reform, but so far this puzzle has not been solved. The theory of dualist democracy proposed by Bruce Ackerman, an American constitutional scholar, can provide new theoretical resources for the resolution of the dilemma of "benign unconstitutional". In the context of the duality of daily politics and constitutional moment, constitutional moment indicates that the country is at a constitutional moment in need of major transformation, and "unconstitutional" unconventional actions are often the necessary conditions to realize social reform. In this stage, the people came out and deeply interacted with the politicians and finally approved the whole reform. The will of the people solved the legitimacy problem of unconventional transformation. The formation process of the 1982 Constitution of China and the economic system reform from the late 1970s to the early 21st century can be regarded as two constitutional moments in the history of our constitution, and those "unconstitutional" unconventional measures should be understood in this context. The unconventionality is the inevitable logic of the major constitutional transformation, and the mobilization of the people during this period gives the unconventional reform measures a legitimacy. |
起訖頁 | 18-37 |
關鍵詞 | 良性違憲、二元民主論、憲法時刻、非常規性、人民動員、Benign Unconstitutional、the Theory of Dualist Democracy、Constitutional Moment、Unconventionality、the Mobilization of the People |
刊名 | 厦门大学法律评论 |
出版單位 | 廈門大學法學院 |
期數 | 202404 (38期) |
DOI | 10.53106/615471682024040038002 複製DOI DOI申請 |
QRCode | |