月旦知識庫
 
  1. 熱門:
 
首頁 臺灣期刊   法律   公行政治   醫事相關   財經   社會學   教育   其他 大陸期刊   核心   重要期刊 DOI文章
篇名
搶劫信用卡並使用行為的定性新探——以信用卡的財產價值為視角
並列篇名
A New Probe into the Qualitative of the Behavior of Robbing Credit Card and Using It--From the Perspective of the Property Value of Credit Card
作者 夏尊文
中文摘要 有關司法解釋將搶劫信用卡並使用的行為定性為搶劫罪,學術界則對這種行為的定性爭訟紛紜。從法理上講,這種行為的定性首先需要在信用卡卡片、帳號兩個層面分開評價。搶卡行為完成之後,卡片層面的搶劫既遂。對帳號層面的搶卡行為與用卡行為的評價需要考慮帳號內有無存款,若有,則帳號為總的債權憑證,存款為分的債權憑證,取得分的債權憑證的行為性質由取得總的債權憑證的行為性質即搶劫決定;若無,則帳號沒有財產價值,帳號層面的搶卡行為是後續用卡行為的預備行為,用卡透支的行為是取得財產的行為,此時需要區分當場還是事後透支將用卡行為分別評價為搶劫罪或信用卡詐騙罪。搶劫借記卡並使用的,帳號層面的犯罪既遂以行為人通過交易取得存款或者現金法律佔有的外觀為標準。相關司法解釋對這種行為的定性在某些情況下有違罪刑法定原則,值得反思。
英文摘要 The related judicial interpretation had been determined the qualitative of the behavior of robbing credit card and using it as robbery, and the academic circles have different opinions on this behavior. Jurisprudentially, the qualitative of this behavior first needs to evaluate separately on two levels of the credit card and account. After credit card robbery, the card-level robbery had been accomplished. The evaluation of the behavior of grabbing credit card and using credit card on account–level needs to consider whether there are deposits in the account, if there are, the account number is total credit certificate, and deposits are the divided credit certificates, the nature of the behavior of obtaining divided credit certificates is determined by the nature of the behavior of obtaining the total credit certificate which is robbery; if not, the account has no property value, and the behavior of grabbing credit card on account–level is a preparatory behavior for subsequent behavior of using credit card, and the behavior of using the credit card to overdraw is the act of acquiring property, at this time, it is necessary to distinguish overdraft between on-the-spot and afterwards, and then evaluate the behavior of using credit card as crime of robbery or credit card fraud. For robbery and use of debit card, the standard of crime accomplished on account-level is that the actor had been obtained the appearance of deposit or cash legal possession through transaction. The nature of this kind of behavior given by relevant judicial interpretations violate the legal principle of criminal punishment in some cases, and it is worthy of reflection.
起訖頁 176-187
關鍵詞 信用卡總的債權憑證分的債權憑證事實佔有法律佔有外觀Credit CardTotal Credit CertificateDivided Credit CertificatesFact PossessionLegal PossessionAppearance
刊名 厦门大学法律评论
出版單位 廈門大學法學院
期數 202204 (33期)
DOI 10.53106/615471682022040033010  複製DOI  DOI申請
QRCode
 



讀者服務專線:+886-2-23756688 傳真:+886-2-23318496
地址:臺北市館前路28 號 7 樓 客服信箱
Copyright © 元照出版 All rights reserved. 版權所有,禁止轉貼節錄