月旦知識庫
 
  1. 熱門:
 
首頁 臺灣期刊   法律   公行政治   醫事相關   財經   社會學   教育   其他 大陸期刊   核心   重要期刊 DOI文章
篇名
台灣醫療糾紛訴訟中實施並發證據的專家證人制度之探討
並列篇名
Implementing a Concurrent Evidence Expert Witness System in Taiwan’s Medical Malpractice Litigation
作者 高銘佑
中文摘要 台灣醫療糾紛的訴訟效率低且相當失敗,提供專家意見的醫事審議委員會需要數月或一年以上才能作出鑑定報告,且法院又經常要委託其他的再鑑定,更進一步拖延鑑定過程的時間。
學者推薦使訴訟程序更有效的一種可能的改革是實施「英美」專家證人制度,專家由當事人聘請,且必須在法庭上作證。這一建議往往過於籠統,且沒有認清在不同的普通法司法管轄。
本文介紹了美國和英國的專家證人制度,並討論了在英國最近修正的民事訴訟法,借助來自澳大利亞所發展的,允許審判中使用並發證據。
這表明,儘管它可能更利於台灣尋找來自與它共享法律傳統的大陸法系國家的指引,有可能仍然值得借用發展自普通法司法管轄的某些程序法,以改革令人失望的制度。
英文摘要 Medical malpractice litigation in Taiwan is marred by inefficiency. Medical review committees that provide expert opinion take months or years to produce reports, and oftentimes courts commission additional assessments that further delay the process. One possible reform recommended by scholars to make the litigation process more efficient is the implementation of an “Anglo-American” expert witness system where experts are hired by the parties and must testify in court. This recommendation is often overly general and fails to recognize the differences in the expert witness systems of various common law jurisdictions. This article introduces the expert witness systems in the United States and the United Kingdom and discusses recent amendments to civil procedure rules in the United Kingdom that allow for concurrent evidence to be used in trial, a development borrowed from Australia. It suggests that although it may be more beneficial for Taiwan to look for guidance from civil law countries with which it shares a legal tradition, there may still be value in borrowing certain procedural law developments from common law jurisdictions to reform the broken system.
起訖頁 21-35
關鍵詞 專家證人制度醫療糾紛訴訟醫事審議委員會並發證據Expert Witness SystemMedical Malpractice LitigationMedical Review CommitteesConcurrent Evidence
刊名 醫事法學
出版單位 中華民國醫事法律學會
期數 201512 (22:2期)
DOI 10.3966/207976642015122202002  複製DOI  DOI申請
QRCode
 



讀者服務專線:+886-2-23756688 傳真:+886-2-23318496
地址:臺北市館前路28 號 7 樓 客服信箱
Copyright © 元照出版 All rights reserved. 版權所有,禁止轉貼節錄