篇名 | 合併仲裁法律問題思辨 |
---|---|
並列篇名 | Reflection and Analysis on the Legal Problems of Consolidation of Arbitration |
作者 | 張建 |
中文摘要 | 多方當事人交易模式革新極易衍生多方多合同爭議,而傳統之分案獨立仲裁顯然無法完滿契合實踐需要,由此緣起對合併仲裁之需求。但就理論與實踐層面契合度而言,合併仲裁向來受到商事仲裁保密性、意思自治原則、操作程式、司法監督具體設置等不同法律問題之指摘,以現代商業視角觀之,這些難題都可以得到彌合。以立足於合併仲裁實務與理論層面之法律問題為導向,在闡明了同步開庭、集團仲裁、仲裁第三人、合併審理與合併仲裁相區分基礎上,合併仲裁決定權之歸屬問題、合併仲裁需要考量之因素、合併後當事人之地位列明問題、合併後之仲裁庭組庭問題、仲裁費用問題成為仲裁實踐需要克服之操作難點。透過捕捉2010年以來國內外各大商事仲裁機構最新仲裁規則修訂過程中對相關問題推進之新走向,結合國外代表性案例對規則文本評析,採取理論與實務相互關照之綜合方法來研究,以凸顯問題在中國之實踐意義以及國際上不同問題解決方案利弊比較。 |
英文摘要 | Multi-party contract disputes derived from the innovation of Multiparty transaction mode easily, while the traditional separate arbitration mode is apparently unable to meet the need of practice, there arises the demand of consolidated arbitration. Considering the theory and practice of consolidation of arbitration, it has always been accused of setting different specific legal problems with commercial arbitration confidentiality, party autonomy principle, operation procedure, judicial supervision and so on. But from the perspective of modern business, these problems can be settled properly. This article concentrates on the legal problems about the practice and theory of consolidated arbitration. The author selected the following questions such as the holder of the authority to order consolidation, the elements to be considered when deciding consolidation, how to display the position of parties involving arbitration, how to constitute the arbitral tribunal after consolidation, and arbitration fees. Through analyz- ing the new trends of addressing issues related in the newest arbitration rules of major domestic and international commercial arbitration institutions after 2010, combined with some foreign representative case analysis, the author has used both the theoretical and empirical methods to make the serious problems clear in China and evaluate international practice by comparing advantages and disadvantages of various solutions. |
起訖頁 | 149-218 |
關鍵詞 | 合併仲裁、合併審理、保密性、意思自治、Consolidation of Arbitration、Joint Trial、Confidentiality |
刊名 | 世新法學 |
出版單位 | 世新大學法學院 |
期數 | 201612 (10:1期) |
DOI | 10.3966/199815542016121001004 複製DOI DOI申請 |
QRCode | |