The unique pathophysiological effects of cardiopulmonary bypass can alter the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of anesthetics, increasing the risk of in-advertent intraoperative awareness, a rare but devastating complication of cardiac surgery. Anesthesiologists commonly rely on the bispectral index (BIS) to ensure appropriate anesthesia depth; however, different anesthetics exhibit distinct electro-encephalogram (EEG) signatures, thereby influencing BIS values differently. Herein, we present the case of a 58-year-old patient undergoing on-pump beating-heart cor-onary artery bypass grafting (CABG) and the anesthesia was maintained with mid-azolam and fentanyl during cardiopulmonary bypass. We observed a peculiar phe-nomenon that despite administering higher doses, BIS values remained above our target range. This elevation in BIS values was inconsistent with the observed clinical manifestations. After the administration of a very small dose of propofol, the BIS decreased dramatically and disproportionately. The discrepancy between BIS values and actual anesthesia depth prompted a detailed exploration of the patient’s EEG patterns. We observed a subtle alternation in the power spectral densities of EEG signals associated with propofol administration, which emphasizes the importance of interpreting BIS values with caution, considering the clinical context and medica-tion. Our findings may facilitate the improvement of anesthesia care during complex cardiac procedures.