月旦知識庫
 
  1. 熱門:
 
首頁 臺灣期刊   法律   公行政治   醫事相關   財經   社會學   教育   其他 大陸期刊   核心   重要期刊 DOI文章
月旦法學雜誌 本站僅提供期刊文獻檢索。
  【月旦知識庫】是否收錄該篇全文,敬請【登入】查詢為準。
最新【購點活動】


篇名
「他們看見了抗議」(下)──認知反自由主義和言論/行為區分/Dan M. Kahan等(譯文)
並列篇名
“They Saw a Protest”: Cognitive Illiberalism and the Speech-Conduct Distinction
作者 張翔宇
中文摘要
文化性認知是個人之團體認同對其認知法律上重要事實的潛意識影響。本文以實驗方法評估文化認知對事實認知的影響,此事實關乎區辨「言論」(受憲法保護)與「行為」(不受憲法保護)。受試者觀看政治示威的影片:半數相信示威者在墮胎診所外抗議墮胎;另一半在軍方招募中心外抗議軍方「不問也不說」的政策。相反文化觀的受試者,若分配到相同的實驗條件(因此對抗議本質的認知相同),對關鍵的「事實」有很不同的看法—包括抗議者是否妨礙或威脅路人。當受試者有同樣文化觀,但被分配到不同的實驗條件(因此對抗議本質的認知不同),對關鍵的「事實」也有很不同的看法。此實證發現支持了研究假設,即文化性認知影響了對言論與行為分野的觀感。本文最後討論研究結果對憲法學與自治的自由主義原則的重要性。
英文摘要
“Cultural cognition”refers to the unconscious influence of individuals’group commitments on their perceptions of legally consequential facts. We conducted an experiment to assess the impact of cultural cognition on perceptions of facts relevant to distinguishing constitutionally protected“speech”from unprotected“conduct.”Study subjects viewed a video of a political demonstration. Half the subjects believed that the demonstrators were protesting abortion outside of an abortion clinic, and the other half that the demonstrators were protesting the military’s“don’t ask, don’t tell”policy outside a military recruitment center. Subjects of opposing cultural outlooks who were assigned to the same experimental condition (and thus had the same belief about the nature of the protest) disagreed sharply on key“facts”—including whether the protestors obstructed and threatened pedestrians. Subjects also disagreed sharply with those who shared their cultural outlooks but who were assigned to the opposing experimental condition (and hence had a different belief about the nature of the protest). These results supported the study hypotheses about how cultural cognition would affect perceptions pertinent to the speech-conduct distinction. We discuss the significance of the results for constitutional law and liberal principles of self-governance generally.
起訖頁 177-192
關鍵詞 文化認知消除偏見陪審團實驗言論行為Cultural CognitionDebiasJuryExperimentSpeechConduct
刊名 月旦法學雜誌  
期數 202309 (340期)
出版單位 元照出版公司
DOI 10.53106/1025593134011   複製DOI
QRCode
該期刊-上一篇 區段徵收之抵價地分配
 

新書閱讀



最新影音


優惠活動




讀者服務專線:+886-2-23756688 傳真:+886-2-23318496
地址:臺北市館前路28 號 7 樓 客服信箱
Copyright © 元照出版 All rights reserved. 版權所有,禁止轉貼節錄