商業法院之管轄範圍：若干事件之檢討

Scope of Commercial Court's Jurisdiction: Certain Examples

就商業事件審理法之施行，本文以若干事件為例，探討是否屬於該法所稱之商業事件，而為商業法院所管轄，指出現行規定對於股東向受託義務人之求償、公司或股東向控制股東之求償、股份收買請求權侵害之求償，均難以落入商業訴訟事件的定義當中。另外，現行法對於董事及監察人之資訊請求，以及非合意收購收購方對於不當防禦措施之對抗，亦未列入。本文認為後續或可斟酌內部事務原則之精神，透過修正現行規定或由司法院指定之方式，加以調整。

Using certain examples to examine the scope of the commercial court's scope of jurisdiction under the Commercial Case Adjudication Act, this article indicates that under current rules, events such as shareholder's claim for compensation against the fiduciary, the claim of shareholder or company against controlling shareholder for damage compensation, infringement of appraisal right do not fall within the definition of commercial event and thus are not covered by the commercial court. In addition, the current rule does not cover the information request by the director or supervisor as well as the bidder's contest against unreasonable defensive measures in the hostile takeover context. This article argues that the current rule may be modified based on the spirit of the internal affairs doctrine.