Pneumoperitoneum is an ominous imaging sign and is frequently seen in conditions that require surgical intervention. However, surgery can be avoided in some unique cases presenting with pneumoperitoneum. We present the case of an 83-year-old man who reported to our emergency department with the chief complaints of fever and right upper quadrant pain for one week. Although abdominal computed tomography revealed definite pneumoperitoneum, it was determined to be a rare case of Pneumatosis coli, wherein surgery could be avoided. Although the diagnosis of pneumoperitoneum is intimidating at best, conservative management should always be considered in cases of minimal abdominal pain and the absence of peritoneal signs, fever, and leukocytosis, as seen in the present case.