嫖宿幼女罪保護法益的正本清源－－兼談嫖宿幼女罪未來的修法方向

A Radical Exploration of Legal Interests of the Crime of Whoring with a Girl under 14: Future Amendment of the Crime of Whoring with a Girl under 14

嫖宿幼女罪保護的並非“社會善良風俗”、“保護幼女”的社會觀念或者“禁止 賣淫嫖娼”的社會管理秩序等社會法益，也不宜界定為“身心健康”或者“健全人格養成”等個人法益。從本罪應然的立法目的考量，應當將其保護的法益界定為“性生理、心理的健全成長權”，而且，嫖宿幼女這一客觀的行為模式也不足以導致對其需要單獨制罪，因此，應當將本罪回歸由姦淫幼女型強姦罪和猥褻兒童罪進行規制，同時考慮到新舊法之間的銜接以及幼女賣淫的特殊動態，建議在強姦罪和猥褻兒童罪中增設對嫖宿幼女行為的相應規定。

Legal interests of the crime of whoring with a girl under 14 is neither the social legal interest like the social attitudes of 'good custom', 'protection of the girl under 14', or the order of social administration to 'prohibit prostitution', etc. nor the individual legal interest of 'physical and mental health', 'development of healthy personality', etc. Considering the legislative purpose of this crime, the legal interests should be 'the right to grow up healthy of sex physiology and sex psychology'. Moreover, objective behavioral pattern of this crime is not sufficient for an independent charge, it should revert to the crime of rape of a girl under 14 and child molestation. And, taking into account the interconnection between the old and new law, and the special dynamic of young girls into prostitution, we propose the creation of the corresponding provisions about the whoring with a girl under 14 in the crimes of rape and child molestation.