雁行理論的研究軌跡:兼為雁行理論駁誤

A Delineation of the Research Trajectory of the Flying Geese Theory and Some Responses to Critics

本文說明國內外雁行理論的研究軌跡，兼為雁行理論駁誤。國外雁行理論的研究論著所在多有，國內部分學者與批評者卻始終有諸多誤解與扭曲，導致國內缺乏雁行理論的研究與論辯空間。本文擬藉由國內外雁行研究論著軌跡的勾勒，指出國內批評者的盲點與局限。本文首先再次簡介赤松要古典雁行理論的內涵與命題，介紹當代雁行理論研究的焦點與趨勢。其次針對筆者遭遇的審查意見與評論，提出澄清與反駁，強調外人直接投資與貿易指數分析在雁行研究中的重要性。結論部分摘述本文重點，並提出改進國內學術審查制度的建議，以期拋磚引玉，共同思考如何建構更完善的學術審查制度與環境。

This research note describes the research trajectory of the flying geese theory and refutes the critiques made by some academic reviewers. The paper introduces the classic version of the theory, delineates contemporary studies and debates revolving around the theory, as well as reveals the distortions and biases emerging from the critiques of some Taiwanese academic reviewers. The paper argues that, in Taiwan, the institutional practice of peer review is problematic and needs radical reforms.